Saturday, June 15, 2024
Concordia Sisters of St. Joseph

Concordia Sisters of St. Joseph

Loving God and neighbor without distinction: A pontifical institute of women religious of the Roman Catholic Church


Thirteen Catholic groups ask Pope Francis to rescind papal bulls from 15th century

The Sisters of St. Joseph of Concordia have joined 12 other Catholic groups requesting that Pope Francis issue a formal rescission of the 15th century papal bulls that provide the basis for the Doctrine of Discovery.

Joining with the elected leadership of the Concordia sisters to make the request are the Loretto Community, and the elected leadership of the Sisters of Mercy of the Americas, the 19 member congregations of Dominican Sisters Conference, the Sisters of St Francis (Rochester, Minn.), Sisters of St. Joseph of Philadelphia, Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth (Kan.), the Congregation of Sisters of St. Agnes (Fond du Lac, Wis.), Institute of the Blessed Virgin Mary (Casa Loreto, Rome), Sisters of St. Joseph and Associates of Buffalo, N.Y.; Pax Christi International; as well as the 8th Day Center for Justice, which is funded by 34 congregations of religious men and women; and the Franciscan-founded Nevada Desert Experience in collaboration with Chief Johnnie L. Bobb of the Western Shoshone National Council. The membership of the 13 groups includes women and men religious and laypeople.

The groups’ request stands in solidarity with indigenous peoples’ persistent requests to every pope since 1984 to do the same.

Columbus’ arrival in the Western Hemisphere began an era of horrific violence based on religious intolerance. The Doctrine of Discovery justified this violence in addition to the seizure of any land not owned by Christians. In their letter dated Nov. 25, the groups call on Pope Francis to start a new era of justice with a public declaration that formally rescinds Dum Diversis Bull of 1452, which granted the pope’s blessing “to capture, vanquish and subdue the Saracens, pagans and other enemies of Christ and put them into perpetual slavery and to take all their possessions and their property,” and Inter Caetera Bull of 1493, which granted authority to Spain and Portugal to “take all lands and possessions” so long as no other Christian ruler had previously claimed them. 

Today’s relationships between governments and indigenous people in the Americas, Africa and Oceania have as their foundation the “Doctrine of Discovery.” It is a principle of international law with roots dating back to 15th century papal bulls. These decrees largely were used to justify Western Europe’s dominion over lands occupied for thousands of years by indigenous peoples. They made possible the European age of “discovery,” sanctioning and promoting the conquest, colonization and exploitation of non-Christian lands and peoples.

 The groups also ask Pope Francis to create a new papal bull that promotes ethical norms in harmony with Gospel values.

Other Catholics have raised their voices in solidarity with this worldwide indigenous peoples’ request, notably Pax Christi International in a prior communication to the World Council of Churches, and the Religious at the United Nations signing a letter to Pope Francis originated by the Passionists International. It is likely that other Catholics have similarly stood as allies, and more are expected to experience the call to do so. All voices in solidarity are welcome. 

The requested actions would be a moral victory for indigenous people, and one long overdue. Recent popes have made gestures of reconciliation, moving the Catholic Church and the world at large forward to this important moment. Indigenous groups stand firm in their requests for rescission and repudiation of the official bulls, seeking the same formality with which they were issued. The 13 groups stand in solidarity with these requests of indigenous neighbors, far and near.

These groups draw inspiration from their Catholic heritage and Gospel values of peace and justice. Many members of these communities were shocked to learn of the doctrine, saddened at the delay experienced by indigenous peoples and eager to show solidarity with the justice-based effort. The past year for many communities has been one of slowly coming to terms with something that indigenous peoples have experienced for centuries.

The 13 Catholic groups making this request join with other denominations that have made similar announcements, including the World Council of Churches, the Episcopal House of Bishops, the Philadelphia, New York and Canadian Yearly Meetings of the Religious Society of Friends and the Boulder Friends Meeting (Quakers), the United Methodist Church, Unitarian Universalists and many others.

To join in this effort, please contact Sister Regina Ann Brummel (


3 thoughts on “Thirteen Catholic groups ask Pope Francis to rescind papal bulls from 15th century

  • Roy Williams

    Thanks For Keeping The Faith Alive Sisters. So Much Is Needed For Our Catholic Schools And Youth. Please Continue To Educate Our Leaders So They Will Always Have The Tools To Work With God’s Creations. Many Thanks.

  • Elizabeth (Betsy) Gasperich-Miller

    I’m with you on this one, dear Sisters. So much injustice……..Prayers and healing energies are sent to Pope Francis. I’m sure that he will do what is fair, just and will stand up with integrity. He certainly has displayed being a man of the people, justice and integrity.
    I also say a prayer for Steve Kellmeyer, who is culturally unaware of the truth of Native American tribes. How sad that some have such a skewed perspective … so blind to the truth.
    Good luck dear Sisters…….Justice, Truth and Integrity and certainly Jesus are on your side. Lovingly, Betsy.

  • All the native American tribes were cannibals.
    Have the tribes formally renounced their cannibalism?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.